Why calling yourself an influencer is just plain wrong

Calling yourself an influencer is like buying yourself a T-Shirt with the words: ‘World’s greatest lover’ printed on the front – writes Scott Guthrie.

Calling yourself an influencer is like buying yourself a T-Shirt with the words: ‘World’s greatest lover’ printed on the front. The power to self-appropriate such claims is not within our gift. These descriptors can only be bestowed upon us by others.

It is other people who decide who influencers are; not us. Influencers are called influencers through third-party endorsement because they … er … influence. They are change agents. They form or change opinions. They alter behaviours.

Influencers are not defined by size of reach alone. They aren’t influencers just because they have access to a large following on Instagram. Rather, influencers are influencers because of the impact they have on others. More than being a subject-matter expert, fundamentally it’s about connecting and talking directly with an audience.

The same is true of the moniker: thought leader. For the love of all things sacred, don’t pepper your social media profiles and bios proclaiming you are one.

And, like Narcissus falling in love at the sight of his own reflection, don’t be tempted to post ‘profound’ quotes you’ve thunk up and displayed against a backdrop of waterfalls, or sunsets or forests on Instagram, Facebook or Twitter. Don’t force it. Let it evolve.


Jay Baer, the digital marketer and author, puts it well: “Trying to ignite a fire around your own work doesn’t make you a thought leader. It makes you an arsonist”.

Instead, focus on consistently creating compelling content that is both relevant and which resonates with your core audience.

Keep listening to and responding to your audience’s needs. Nurture your following by engaging with them; by answering their questions. Solve their problems. Help them realise their aims.

Show them, don’t just tell them. For, to use a phrase coined by C.G. Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist, “you are what you do. Not what you say you’ll do.”

Influence is accretive. It evolves. It strengthens over time. Influence can’t be built on one-time visitors, but over time visitors become ever-more engaged with the content. More invested in thoughtful points of view.

Influence, thought leadership and being the world’s greatest lover are all founded on credibility which stems from authority.

We have to earn this trust, credibility, and authority we can’t own it by declaring that we possess it. Like reputation, these attributes are the result of what you do, what you say and what others say about you – to re-use part of the Chartered Institute of Public Relations definition of PR.

Get posts like this one direct to your inbox. Subscribe by email using the box on the top right of the screen. You can also follow me on Twitter. I’d like that.

About the Author Scott Guthrie

Scott Guthrie works with companies to drive business growth in the social age through strategic insight and technical know-how. That's not giving you a lot of detail, is it? So, read more here.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment:

David Sawyer @zudepr says February 3, 2017

LOL, will read with glass of vino later:O). d

*David Sawyer FCIPR* Director, Zude PR [image: photo] Phone: +44 (0) 141 569 0342 Mobile: +44 (0) 7770 886923 Email: dave@zudepr.co.uk Website: http://zudepr.co.uk Address: 308 Albert Drive, Pollokshields, Glasgow G41 5RS Conquer your digital marketing fear:Get Free Digital PR Brain Food Weekly: Direct to Your Inbox My latest post:The Top 10 Books of 2016 (According to Zude)

    Scott Guthrie says February 3, 2017

    It’s a short read. Something that’s been niggling for a while. Also trying out new doodles for images. Not long until it’s time for that vino — thanks for stopping by, Dave — Scott

Add Your Reply